Why Pool Homes Are in High Demand in Treasure Island
Treasure Island is a quiet barrier island with wide sandy beaches, stunning sunsets, and a relaxed community atmosphere along the Gulf coast. With a population of 7K and a median home price around $580K, the city offers a compelling blend of lifestyle and value. Pool homes here are especially popular because Florida’s warm subtropical climate allows for year-round outdoor living. Whether you are a family looking for weekend fun, a retiree wanting a private oasis, or a buyer seeking strong resale value, a pool home in Treasure Island is an excellent investment.
Homes with pools in Treasure Island tend to command a premium of 10 to 20 percent compared to similar homes without pools. Buyers consistently rank a private pool as one of their top must-have features, and in a market like Treasure Island, where sunshine is abundant and outdoor entertaining is a way of life, that demand only grows. The neighborhood you choose, the pool type you prefer, and your budget all play important roles in finding the right property.
Popular Neighborhoods for Pool Homes in Treasure Island
Several neighborhoods in Treasure Island stand out for their concentration of pool homes and desirable living conditions. Here are the top areas to explore:
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach is one of the most sought-after neighborhoods in Treasure Island for pool homes. Properties here often feature spacious lots with mature landscaping, screened-in pool enclosures, and updated outdoor kitchens. Many homes back up to canals or offer water views, making a pool the perfect complement to the setting. Prices in Sunset Beach typically range from $435,000 to $870,000 depending on size and updates.
Paradise Island
Paradise Island offers a blend of established charm and modern upgrades. Pool homes in this neighborhood often sit on generous lots with room for expanded patios, fire pits, and tropical landscaping. The area is well-connected to shopping, dining, and major roadways, making it convenient for commuters. Expect pool homes in Paradise Island to start around $435,000 and reach $870,000 or more for renovated properties.
Gulf Boulevard
Gulf Boulevard is known for its family-friendly atmosphere and well-maintained homes. Pool properties here tend to feature newer construction or recently updated interiors with open floor plans that flow seamlessly to a screened lanai and pool area. The neighborhood benefits from proximity to parks, schools, and community amenities. Homes with pools in Gulf Boulevard are typically priced between $580,000 and $1,276,000.
Isle of Palms
Isle of Palms rounds out the top areas for pool home buyers. This neighborhood features a mix of ranch-style and two-story homes, many with updated pools and outdoor living spaces. The tree-lined streets and quiet cul-de-sacs make it a favorite among families. Pool homes in Isle of Palms are generally priced between $435,000 and $870,000.
Pool Home Price Ranges in Treasure Island
Understanding the price landscape helps you set realistic expectations and identify the best opportunities in the Treasure Island pool home market.
| Category | Price Range | What to Expect |
|---|---|---|
| Entry-Level Pool Homes | $435,000 – $580,000 | Smaller pools, older construction, standard screened enclosures |
| Mid-Range Pool Homes | $580,000 – $870,000 | Updated kitchens, heated pools, expanded lanais, 3-4 bedrooms |
| Luxury Pool Homes | $870,000 – $1,276,000+ | Resort-style pools, outdoor kitchens, saltwater systems, water views |
Types of Pools You Will Find in Treasure Island
Not all pools are created equal, and the type of pool a home features can significantly impact maintenance costs, enjoyment, and resale value. Here are the most common pool types in Treasure Island:
- Screened Pools: The most common type in Florida, screened pools feature an aluminum and mesh enclosure that keeps out insects, debris, and provides UV protection. Nearly every pool home in Treasure Island has some form of screen enclosure, known locally as a “cage.” Rescreening typically costs $3,000 to $8,000 depending on size.
- Saltwater Pools: Growing in popularity, saltwater systems use a chlorine generator that creates a gentler, less chemically harsh swimming experience. Many buyers in Treasure Island specifically seek saltwater pools for their lower ongoing chemical costs and softer feel. Conversion from traditional chlorine runs $1,500 to $3,500.
- Heated Pools: While Florida is warm most of the year, winter mornings can cool pool water into the 60s. Electric heat pumps are the most common heating option in Treasure Island and extend comfortable swimming from roughly 8 months to a full 12 months. A quality heat pump costs $3,000 to $6,000 installed.
- Spa and Pool Combos: Many mid-range and luxury pool homes include an attached spa or hot tub. These combined systems offer versatility and are especially popular among buyers who entertain frequently. Expect a premium of $10,000 to $20,000 for homes with spa combos versus standard pools.
- Infinity and Custom Pools: Found primarily in luxury properties priced above $1,276,000, infinity-edge and custom-designed pools with waterfalls, grottos, or swim-up bars represent the top tier of outdoor living in Treasure Island. These homes are rare and tend to sell quickly.
Pool Home Buyer Checklist for Treasure Island
Purchasing a pool home involves additional considerations beyond a standard home purchase. Use this checklist to ensure you are making a well-informed decision:
- Pool Inspection: Always hire a certified pool inspector in addition to your general home inspector. They will check the pump, filter, heater, plumbing lines, pool surface, and screen enclosure. Budget $150 to $300 for a standalone pool inspection.
- Age of Equipment: Ask about the age of the pool pump, filter, heater, and salt cell if applicable. Most pool pumps last 8 to 12 years. Replacing a pump and motor runs $800 to $2,000 depending on the model.
- Resurfacing Timeline: Pool surfaces (plaster, pebble, or tile) typically last 10 to 15 years before needing resurfacing. A full resurface costs $5,000 to $15,000 depending on material and pool size. Ask when the pool was last resurfaced.
- Insurance Considerations: Pools can increase your homeowner’s insurance premium by $50 to $150 per year. A screened enclosure can help mitigate liability concerns. Discuss pool coverage with your insurance agent before closing.
- Monthly Maintenance Costs: Budget $100 to $250 per month for professional pool maintenance if you prefer not to handle it yourself. This includes chemical balancing, cleaning, and equipment checks. Many Treasure Island homeowners find a pool service essential for keeping their pool swim-ready year-round.
- Fence and Safety Requirements: Florida law requires a barrier around residential pools. A screened enclosure satisfies this requirement in most cases, but verify with Pinellas County building codes if the screen is damaged or the pool is unenclosed.
Outdoor Living and Entertainment in Treasure Island
A pool home in Treasure Island is more than just a house with a pool. It represents an entire outdoor lifestyle. The best pool properties feature thoughtfully designed outdoor living spaces that extend usable square footage and create a resort-like atmosphere right at home.
Look for homes with covered lanais that provide shade during the hottest months, outdoor kitchens equipped with grills and bar seating, and tropical landscaping that creates privacy and ambiance. Many pool homes in Sunset Beach and Paradise Island feature upgraded pavers around the pool deck, LED pool lighting for evening swims, and automated pool controls that let you manage temperature and cleaning from your phone.
The outdoor living trend continues to grow in Treasure Island, with buyers increasingly prioritizing usable outdoor space. Homes with well-designed pool areas and lanais consistently sell faster and at higher prices than comparable homes without these features. If you are planning to sell in the future, investing in your outdoor space is one of the best returns you can get in the Treasure Island market.
Why Treasure Island Is a Great Place to Own a Pool Home
Treasure Island stands out among Pinellas County communities for several reasons that make pool home ownership especially rewarding. The city offers a strong sense of community, convenient access to Gulf beaches, quality schools, and a diverse dining and entertainment scene. With a population of 7K, Treasure Island strikes the right balance between having enough amenities for daily convenience and maintaining the neighborhood character that residents love.
The real estate market in Treasure Island has shown steady appreciation over the past decade, with pool homes leading the way in value retention. Buyers from across the country are drawn to the combination of affordable pricing (compared to South Florida), no state income tax, and the ability to enjoy outdoor living 12 months a year. Whether you are relocating from the Northeast, upgrading from a non-pool home, or searching for a vacation property, Treasure Island delivers outstanding value.
For personalized guidance on finding the perfect pool home, contact Barrett Henry for a consultation. You can also explore the home selling resources if you need to sell before buying.
Frequently Asked Questions About Treasure Island Pool Homes
How much does a pool home cost in Treasure Island?
Pool homes in Treasure Island generally range from $435,000 for entry-level properties up to $1,276,000 or more for luxury homes with resort-style pools. The median price for a pool home typically runs 10 to 20 percent above the overall market median of $580K. Pricing depends on neighborhood, lot size, pool condition, and overall home features.
Are pool homes a good investment in Treasure Island?
Yes. Pool homes in Treasure Island consistently hold their value well and tend to appreciate at or above the overall market rate. A well-maintained pool adds measurable value to a property in Florida, where outdoor living is a key selling point. Buyers relocating from colder climates specifically seek pool homes, which supports demand and pricing stability year-round.
How much does it cost to maintain a pool in Treasure Island?
Monthly pool maintenance in Treasure Island typically costs $100 to $250 if you hire a professional service. This covers chemical balancing, skimming, filter cleaning, and equipment monitoring. DIY maintenance can reduce costs to $50 to $80 per month for chemicals and supplies. Annual expenses for electricity to run the pump average $600 to $1,200 depending on pump efficiency.
What should I look for during a pool inspection?
A thorough pool inspection should cover the pool surface condition (cracks, staining, delamination), pump and filter function, heater operation, plumbing integrity, screen enclosure condition, and deck or paver levelness. The inspector should also test water chemistry and check for any code violations. Always schedule a pool-specific inspection in addition to the standard home inspection.
Do I need a separate pool fence if the pool has a screen enclosure?
In most cases, a screened pool enclosure satisfies Florida’s pool barrier requirements as long as the enclosure is in good condition with a self-closing and self-latching door. However, if the screen is torn or the door mechanism is not functioning, additional safety measures may be required. Always verify current Pinellas County requirements before closing on a pool home purchase.
Find Your Perfect Home in Treasure Island
Barrett Henry helps buyers find the right home in Treasure Island and throughout Tampa Bay.
Barrett Henry, REALTOR® — RE/MAX Collective | (813) 733-7907
Barrett Henry is a licensed REALTOR® with RE/MAX Collective, serving home buyers and sellers throughout Pinellas County and the greater Tampa Bay area. With deep local knowledge and a client-first approach, Barrett provides expert guidance through every step of the real estate process. Whether you are buying your first home, upgrading, downsizing, or investing, Barrett delivers the market insight and personal attention you deserve. Contact Barrett Henry today at (813) 733-7907 or visit the contact page to get started.
