New Construction Homes in Anna Maria: Builders, Communities, and What to Know

New construction homes in Anna Maria, Florida, are an attractive option for buyers who want a modern, move-in-ready home with the latest features and warranties. Whether you are a first-time buyer, upgrading to a larger home, or looking for a low-maintenance property, building new in Anna Maria offers real advantages. Here is what to know before you buy.

Active Builders and Communities

Several builders are active in and around Anna Maria, offering a range of home styles and price points. Current builders include custom island builders, tear-down/rebuild. These builders are developing in communities throughout the area, including neighborhoods near Anna Maria City, Pine Avenue, Bean Point area, bayfront.

Each builder offers different floor plans, included features, and incentive packages. Comparing options carefully – and understanding what is included versus what is an upgrade – is one of the most important steps in buying new construction.

View all available new construction listings on our Anna Maria new construction page.

Why Buy New Construction?

There are several compelling reasons to consider a new-build home in Anna Maria:

• Modern floor plans: Open layouts, larger closets, flex spaces, and multi-generational options
• Energy efficiency: Impact windows, high-efficiency HVAC, spray foam insulation, and solar-ready roofing
• Builder warranties: Structural warranties (typically 10 years), mechanical warranties, and workmanship coverage
• Low maintenance: New roof, new appliances, new systems – nothing to replace for years
• Customization: Choose your lot, floor plan, finishes, and upgrades from the start

For buyers who want to avoid the unknowns of an older home – aging roof, outdated plumbing, worn-out HVAC – new construction eliminates those concerns.

New Construction vs. Resale: What to Consider

While new construction has clear advantages, it is worth comparing to resale homes in Anna Maria:

• Price per square foot: New homes often cost more per square foot, but you get modern features and warranties in return
• Location: Resale homes may be in more established neighborhoods with mature trees and closer-in locations
• Timeline: A resale home can close in 30-45 days; new construction may take 4-8 months depending on the stage
• Landscaping and community: Newer communities may still be under development, while resale neighborhoods are fully built out

Many buyers find that the long-term savings on maintenance and energy costs make new construction the better value over time.

What to Negotiate With Builders

Contrary to popular belief, you can negotiate when buying new construction. Here are areas where buyers often find savings:

• Closing cost credits: Many builders offer $5,000-$15,000+ in closing cost assistance, especially when using their preferred lender
• Upgrades and options: Builders may include upgraded appliances, flooring, or countertops as part of the deal
• Lot premiums: Some lot premiums are negotiable, especially on less desirable positions
• Rate buydowns: Builders with affiliated mortgage companies may offer interest rate buydowns

Having your own agent represent you in a new construction purchase costs you nothing – the builder pays the agent’s commission – and your agent can negotiate on your behalf and review the builder contract for potential issues.

Timeline and What to Expect

If you buy a new construction home in Anna Maria in 2026, here is a typical timeline:

• Pre-construction / lot selection: 1-2 weeks
• Permitting: 2-6 weeks
• Construction: 4-6 months (frame to completion)
• Inspections and closing: 2-4 weeks

If you purchase a quick move-in (QMI) home that is already under construction or complete, the timeline shortens significantly – sometimes to just 30-60 days.

For a complete look at all homes available in Anna Maria, including resale options, visit our Anna Maria real estate hub.

Work With Barrett Henry

I help buyers navigate the new construction process in Anna Maria every day. From selecting the right builder and floor plan to negotiating upgrades and reviewing contracts, I will make sure you get the best possible deal. My services cost you nothing – the builder pays my commission.

Call or text me at (813) 733-7907, email barrett@nowtb.com, or visit my contact page to get started.

Barrett Henry is a Broker Associate at RE/MAX Collective with over 23 years of experience helping buyers purchase new construction homes in Anna Maria, Manatee County, and the Tampa Bay area. Barrett provides expert representation throughout the builder process at no cost to the buyer. Learn more at nowtb.com.